Policy Document

You are here

DOT Rule 49 CFR Part 40 Section 40.389

Subpart R - Public Interest Exclusions

§ 40.389 What factors may the Director consider?
 
This section lists examples of the kind of mitigating and aggravating factors that the Director may consider in determining whether to issue a PIE concerning you, as well as the scope and duration of a PIE. This list is not exhaustive or exclusive. The Director may consider other factors if appropriate in the circumstances of a particular case. The list of examples follows:
 
(a) The actual or potential harm that results or may result from your noncompliance;
 
(b) The frequency of incidents and/or duration of the noncompliance;
 
(c) Whether there is a pattern or prior history of noncompliance;
 
(d) Whether the noncompliance was pervasive within your organization, including such factors as the following:
 
(1) Whether and to what extent your organization planned, initiated, or carried out the noncompliance;
 
(2) The positions held by individuals involved in the noncompliance, and whether your principals tolerated their noncompliance; and
 
(3) Whether you had effective standards of conduct and control systems (both with respect to your own organization and any contractors or affiliates) at the time the noncompliance occurred;
 
(e) Whether you have demonstrated an appropriate compliance disposition, including such factors as the following:
 
(1) Whether you have accepted responsibility for the noncompliance and recognize the seriousness of the conduct that led to the cause for issuance of the PIE;
 
(2) Whether you have cooperated fully with the Department during the investigation. The Director may consider when the cooperation began and whether you disclosed all pertinent information known to you;
 
(3) Whether you have fully investigated the circumstances of the noncompliance forming the basis for the PIE and, if so, have made the result of the investigation available to the Director;
 
(4) Whether you have taken appropriate disciplinary action against the individuals responsible for the activity that constitutes the grounds for issuance of the PIE; and
 
(5) Whether your organization has taken appropriate corrective actions or remedial measures, including implementing actions to prevent recurrence;
 
(f) With respect to noncompliance with a DOT agency regulation, the degree to which the noncompliance affects matters common to the DOT drug and alcohol testing program;
 
(g) Other factors appropriate to the circumstances of the case.
Updated: Thursday, November 29, 2012